i want to try to write a post that is focused on a single topic. i feel nervous and shy, shaky (even though the types of blogs i’m modeling this after will probably never see it.) there really is a huge difference between journal entries and blogs-as-informal-journalism. is there room for both, here? i’d like to think so.
i have a great deal of privilege. as i start to pass for male (which still doesn’t happen all the time, despite what my friends might kindly think), i have yet another thing to add to the list, which already includes: white, educated, dominant culture, able-bodied, non-stigmatized weight/appearance, and probably more (please let me know if you think of something i should add!) clearly, if i want to be a part of social change, my role is going to be frequently, maybe primarily, that of an ally. i’m really interested in being a good ally, and i think one of the most important behaviors is to be able to admit when i make mistakes, run into blind spots, act on prejudice, ignore the experience of others.
i also belong to some oppressed groups: poor (though for me it is a privilege to live in the city, and being poor is part of the cost), disabled, queer, trans, survivor.
what i want to write about is the intersection between that last (which of course interacts a lot with being disabled), and the privilege i do have. i don’t have a thesis or everything figured out. i’ve just noticed something that really bears thinking about. before the other day, it didn’t even occur to me to include being a survivor as being part of an oppressed group. but via questioning transphobia, i found this: non-survivor privilege and silence. wow, that was an amazing thing to read. i was having a hard time already, but there were some definite tears of recognition in my eyes from reading that. really, go read it.
as a survivor, i’m pretty experienced at doubting myself, at deferring. if i disagree with someone, i’m liable to defer to them before i think (or even suppress the disagreement before i’m aware of it.) i tend to think i don’t have the right to take up space. i spend a lot of time trying to be invisible. i’m not saying that these things negate my privilege. hell, i am able to be invisible in large part because of my privilege. but i do think they interact.
part of being a good ally is not being silent and therefore complicit. if i keep my mouth shut when people are fucked-up about groups i don’t belong to, then i am participating in the atmosphere that allows oppression.
the other week, i had a really eye-opening experience. i was with ej at a social gathering (that makes me sound like i have so much more of a life than i do), and a person came into the group who made a lot of people uncomfortable. he made a racist comment, saying that at a bar the person he was with abandoned him for “some mexican boy.” prosody is part of meaning and the emphasis (on top of mentioning race when it did not seem to be relevant) was clearly racist. in hindsight, this is really clear. and at the time, when he said it, i remember feeling surprised/uncomfortable at the comment, but quickly assuming i did not understand the full context of the story. i was concentrating on being social and likable, which is a huge strain for me anyway. i accepted what he was saying without much of a blip in my consciousness at all, because these processes are so automatic for me.
later in the afternoon, he had gone away, and the people that were still there spoke of relief about him being gone. they congratulated one person for going out of her way to mention racism rather pointedly while talking about her classes (she is a sociology professor… i know i sound even more like i have a real life, but this was the only time i’ve been in that cool of a crowd, i swear.) i didn’t notice the pointedness, though i did really appreciate what she was talking about and was frankly fascinated by everything she had to say. when people congratulated her, i realized which comment had been racist, and remembered my discomfort. i felt really bad, really backwards, that i hadn’t been more critical of the guy in my thoughts earlier. but that’s the thing. i never feel i have a right to be critical.
i could give so many other examples from my life with aeron. (he thought it was a huge joke to nickname our anorexic part “fattie”. he practically defines hipster bigotry.) and as i was saying yesterday, i think not criticizing aeron has/had been a part of my survival for years.
i also really worry about my social anxiety making me seem like or become an asshole. i am quiet, tense, deferential around strangers. i give them a lot of space, especially when i’m having a hard time. for example, on the bus, i generally prefer standing to sitting right beside a stranger. if aeron is there though, i’ll try to find him a seat even if i can’t have one, since he has hip problems. i was doing this on the muni in san francisco and a large black woman noticed and patted the seat next to her. normally i would just try as politely as i could to say no, but i worried so much she would think it was because i didn’t want to be next to her. so when aeron wouldn’t sit, i did.
also in san francisco, on a crowded bart car, a person in a wheelchair was having a lot of trouble getting in… the door didn’t line up very neatly to the platform. they had to try like four times. i really wanted to help, but there was no way i could handle that level of interacting with someone. i was really pissed at the rest of the car for just ignoring this person, but how could i be when i didn’t get up and help? (they finally made it in on their own.)
i want to find my way through this thicket without making excuses for myself. when does my valid experience end and the making excuses start?
on the plus side, healing from my abuse will make it easier to be assertive. but in some ways my personality has been permanently shaped by what i went through. how can i be an ally if i am not able or willing to speak up, help, challenge privilege? is there a solution, or can i only notice the problem?
even noticing the problem is a part of this whole interaction, because at times we really beat ourselves up over it. we beat ourselves up over everything. when is the beating-up valid shame at my privileged place in society, and when is it just an excuse to be down on myself?
as i said at the beginning, i don’t really have answers.








